If you’re an adult beginner looking to learn piano at home, chances are you’ve come across both Pianoforall and Simply Piano. Both are popular online courses — but they offer very different learning experiences.
So which one is better suited to your goals, time, and learning style?
In this head-to-head comparison, we’ll compare the top beginner piano courses side-by-side, so you can make an informed decision.
🎹 Want our full take on Pianoforall’s pros, cons, and value? Read our full 2025 review here
🧩 Learning Style: App vs Book-Based
- Simply Piano: App-based, like Duolingo for piano. It listens to your playing via microphone and unlocks lessons based on accuracy.
- Pianoforall: Downloadable eBooks with embedded video/audio, allowing offline, self-paced learning. No mic needed.
✅ Best for: Learners who want freedom over structure — Pianoforall.
🎹 Focus: Playing Songs vs Theory First
- Simply Piano: Starts with reading notes, theory, and hand placement — then gradually introduces songs.
- Pianoforall: Starts with chords and rhythm, so you’re playing recognizable songs within days.
✅ Best for: People who want to sound musical fast — Pianoforall.
👨🏫 Who It’s Made For
- Simply Piano: Family-friendly, good for kids and casual learners who like gamified progress.
- Pianoforall: Designed specifically for adult beginners, guitarists switching to piano, and creative types who want to play by feel.
✅ Best for: Adult learners with a strong interest in modern music — Pianoforall.
💸 Pricing in 2025
- Simply Piano: Subscription model ($149/year or $14.99/month)
- Pianoforall: One-time payment (usually $49–$79 for lifetime access)
✅ Best for: Long-term value and flexibility — Pianoforall.
📈 Progress Experience
- Simply Piano: Feels more like a structured course with badges and levels. Great if you want that “unlock as you go” feel.
- Pianoforall: No tracking, but high flexibility. You can jump around and revisit modules freely.
✅ Best for: Independent learners who don’t need gamification — Pianoforall.
⭐ Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Learning Style | Pianoforall |
| Song-First Approach | Pianoforall |
| Adult-Focused Design | Pianoforall |
| Long-Term Value | Pianoforall |
| Gamified Learning | Simply Piano |
While Simply Piano is great for families and young learners, Pianoforall is the clear winner for adults who want to play real songs quickly and grow at their own pace.
🎹 Ready to compare the top beginner piano courses side-by-side? Dive deeper into our full Pianoforall review.